Fly fishing for trout at Gunpowder Falls State Park

There is a reason the sport is called 'fishing' and not 'catching'; though I expect most fly anglers would agree that the 'catching' is what motivates the 'fishing'. And while challenging fishing experience can still be satisfying, I admit to feeling somewhat aggrieved when a sustained focus on skill and technique goes unrewarded after a hard day of fishing. This happens often in Gunpowder Falls State Park, which is why I regard the Gunpowder River as a nemesis of sorts.
The Gunpowder is equal parts tranquility at its finest and blue-ribbon trout water. It is featured in Trout Unlimited’s Guide to America’s 100 Best Trout Streams and therein is referred to as a “premier metropolitan wild trout fishery” of the East. Although it is only 25 miles from Baltimore, authors Charlie Gelso and Larry Coburn refer to the Gunpowder as a “civilized wilderness” in their guide to Maryland Trout Fishing.
But fishing this water becomes a reckoning of sorts for the dedicated fly angler. The only thing easy about fishing the Gunpowder is that it is accessible and reasonably wadable. After that, the fly angler is left to their own devices to crack the code as the largely brown trout population is famously wary due to high pressure and environmental conditions that work in their favor.

Which is why, after more than a decade of fishing this water (admittedly, about once a year), I called in reinforcements to help me upgrade my approach to fishing the Gunpowder. Fellow TU member and local guide, Kiki Galvin of Ms. Guided Fly Fishing, set aside a weekend in early October to coach me and my fishing companion, Lars, on how to enhance the prospect of 'catching' on the Gunpowder.

The Gunpowder River in Gunpowder Falls State Park is a tailwater that originates at Prettyboy Reservoir and is overseen by a cooperative of agencies that manages a controlled release of water from the dam. Maryland Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) has not stocked browns in several decades, which means nearly all brown trout here are wild. The MDNR undertakes only selective stocking of rainbows in the upper section closer to the dam. Native brook trout can also enter the Gunpowder from tributaries that lead to the river.

The trout population on the Gunpowder is impressive – with upwards of 1,500 trout per mile. This facilitates both opportunity and adversity. The stable temperatures translate into prolific insect life, so fish can afford to be picky. This abundant food source trends toward tiny bugs, so smaller flies are more appropriate, and fluctuating flows from the dam releases will affect trout feeding behavior. The dense population also means that fish are competing for limited nutrients and so the average size of brown trout on this river is 8 to 10 inches.
A tailwater strongly influences the behavior of resident trout because of the fluctuating flows. Trout in a tailwater tend to be wary, which requires a more delicate and technical approach. Seeking out disturbances in the water is an advantage – riffles, current breaks and foam lines will act as a shield to your presence, as will targeting structure, such as boulders and sunken tree trunks/limbs. As such, it is advantageous to have close contact with the fly, keeping line and leader off the water. In fishing a dry fly, the leader should remain elevated off the water, thus “fishing the rod tip over the fly” as my guide, Kiki, explained. In this way, the fly is unencumbered and able to drift naturally along the current. Alternatively, fishing deep while contact nymphing is an approach that is also very effective, “leading the fly” (or flies) through the water under the rod tip.

During the autumn weekend of fishing the Gunpowder with guide and fishing companion, we rotated through these various approaches. Weather conditions were pleasant to begin with but became less ideal as a front that preceded our visit dampened the mood of the trout. Apparently, these fish are more active when water temps are below 60 degrees, but the temps exceeded 60 on both days we were on the water. The water was also stained from recent rains, and the overhead conditions were unhelpful. It was hard work for little reward as we fished dries (the preferred), dry / droppers and streamers, despite the constant encouragement and guidance of our guide, Kiki. My fishing companion and I put only three trout in the net over the course of the two days, which only confirmed the nemesis status of the Gunpowder.

I packed a 9ft, 5-wt Orvis Helios, a 9ft, 4-wt TFO (Lefty Kreh signature for obvious reasons) as well as a 10ft, 4-wt Echo carbon nymphing rod, and used all three during this excursion to the Gunpowder. Because the water was stained, we were comfortable fishing 5x leaders but would recommend moving to 6x diameter leaders in clearer water. Identifying the appropriate depth when fishing wet flies is crucial – if fish are not biting, change the depth before changing the fly pattern or size. In the end, the dry flies (mostly caddis patterns) were the most successful.
Keep in mind that felt-soled wading boots are prohibited in Maryland and a state fishing license is required.
Note: I am not being compensated for my mention of Kiki Galvin. I am simply a happy client and good friend.





Comments